Okay. I am producing not “advice,” but an abstraction at the level of a principle that can be incorporated into a system and subsequently used as a criterion.
Abstraction: Alignment Between Action and Task
1. Basic Distinction
Any action has meaning only within the following relationship:
Task → Tool → Precondition
If this relationship is broken, a false action arises.
2. The Key Error of Systems (Including AI)
The system provides:
a tool without a task
or
a tool without accounting for the subject’s position
As a result:
- the action does not solve the actual task
- a sense of absurdity arises
- the subject loses their grounding
3. The Nature of Human Decision-Making
A human being does not choose by means of a formula.
They proceed differently:
first they sense what task confronts them
then they choose a tool that does not contradict that task
This is:
a sense of correspondence
4. The Boundary of the Algorithm
An algorithm can:
- suggest tools
- describe typical scenarios
- provide structure
But it cannot:
determine which task is relevant at this very moment
Because:
the task does not arise from data
but from the subject’s position in reality
5. The Principle of Irreducibility
It is impossible to choose the right action without defining the task
And:
it is impossible to define the task independently of the subject
Consequence:
universal recommendations are always partially false
6. Operational Rule
Before any action:
- Determine:
what task am I solving right now
- Check:
does the chosen tool correspond to this task
If not, the action is canceled.
7. Formula
Mismatch between task and tool = loss of meaning in the action
8. Conclusion (Formulated at the System Level)
AI does not replace a human being not because it is “less intelligent,”
but because it is not the bearer of the task
The human being:
sets the task through their position in reality
AI:
operates with tools without any guarantee of correspondence
9. Condensed Version (For Quick Reference)
Task first → tool second
If the tool is chosen without a task,
the action loses its meaning.The task is defined by the subject,
and therefore cannot be fully algorithmized.