Related materials: simulacrum, hyperreality, ersatz, usurpation of meaning by form, reification, dynamics of form and meaning, distinction.
Introduction
A model can serve as a means of investigating what is happening. A subject distinguishes relationships, constructs a description, returns to the subject matter, and examines what the description retains and what it leaves out. A model can also become a project through which a subject deliberately transforms reality. These relationships are not in themselves simulation in Jean Baudrillard’s specific sense.
A different transition occurs when created signs and models begin to determine the conditions under which reality is presented, while their origin as forms of representation ceases to matter. Subjects and other participants are then offered not simply a description of events but a system in which conformity to the model becomes the basis for recognizing something as “real.”
Term and Definition
The word simulation has several meanings. In technical contexts it can mean reproducing a process’s behavior within a computational model. In everyday speech, it may mean imitation or pretending. For Baudrillard, simulation is reducible to neither of these meanings.
Simulation in the sense examined here is a process in which signs and models not only represent some reality but produce the conditions under which it is presented and recognized; the distinction between representation and what is represented ceases to provide a basis for testing the model.
This is a working reconstruction for the ontology archive, not a verbatim quotation from Baudrillard.
An indicative sequence:
a subject distinguishes relationships in what is happening
→ creates a model or a system of signs
→ the model is used to recognize and organize events
→ conformity to the model becomes a criterion of reality
→ distinctions outside the model lose the power to change the criterion itself
What matters is not the mere fact that a model influences events, but a change in the model’s status: a form that could be tested becomes the authority by which everything else is tested.
Baudrillard: Simulation Is Not the Same as Pretending
At the beginning of “The Precession of Simulacra,” Baudrillard opposes representation and simulation. Representation presupposes a relationship between a sign and what it signifies. Simulation challenges the possibility of maintaining this boundary: signs of the real take the place of the real, and models organize its production.
Baudrillard explicitly distinguishes mere pretending from simulation. In pretending, a determinate boundary remains: a person portrays something that, in the relevant sense, is absent. Simulation can produce actual effects and signs that disturb the customary distinction between the portrayed and the “genuine.”
Therefore, saying “it’s all fake” is insufficient. Simulation can have thoroughly real consequences. The issue is not the absence of events, but the way signs and models participate in establishing their status.
Precession of Simulacra: The Map Precedes the Territory
Drawing on the image of the map and the territory, Baudrillard describes a radical reversal of order: the territory no longer provides the prior foundation for the map; instead, the map precedes and generates the territory. The model no longer functions as a derivative description.
This does not mean that every act of planning or modeling is simulation. A map may be a conscious project, while the territory remains open to further investigation. Baudrillard is describing a regime of signs in which the distinction between a model and its presumed referent no longer organizes the relationship to reality.
Example: University Rankings
- Subjects select indicators of university quality. The indicators retain certain distinctions, but do not exhaust the meaning of education.
- The indicators are aggregated into a ranking, presented as a form of comparison.
- Universities begin reorganizing their activities to improve their position. The ranking now influences what it purports to describe.
- A university’s ranking may then become the principal criterion of “quality” itself. The question of which relationships to education mattered originally recedes.
The third step demonstrates feedback from a model into practice. The fourth shows a possible transition to simulation in the sense examined here. Not every instance of feedback constitutes simulation.
The indicators exist, people’s decisions are real, and organizational changes occur. Simulation does not cancel their reality. It becomes visible in which form acquires the authority to define the meaning of these changes.
Simulation and Deliberate Transformation
A subject can draw up a house plan and then build a house according to it. Or devise the rules of a game and create an actual practice of playing. Here the model precedes the result, but this does not make the result “unreal” or establish simulation in Baudrillard’s sense.
We must distinguish:
a subject uses a model to transform what happens
≠
a model gains the authority to determine what may count as happening at all
In the first case, the subject can retain the distinction between the project and the result, revising the project upon discovering something new. In the second, conformity to the model becomes a condition for accepting what has been distinguished: what does not fit the form may be excluded from consideration.
Simulation, Simulacrum, and Hyperreality
| Concept | What it identifies | Main question |
|---|---|---|
| Simulacrum | The status of an image or sign that begins to take the place of what it signifies | What does the image represent, and how did it acquire independent status? |
| Simulation | The production and reproduction of reality through signs and models | How does the model change the conditions of what is accepted as real? |
| Hyperreality | A regime in which the distinction between model and real no longer serves as an effective criterion | How do subjects and participants distinguish the real within a system of models? |
This is an analytical distinction useful for the archive. In Baudrillard’s own writings, these notions are closely intertwined and are not invariably used as three consecutive stages.
Connection to an Ontology of Distinction
Simulation allows us to examine a concrete mechanism of the usurpation of meaning by form.
a subject's act of distinction
→ a form that retains the distinction
→ a reproducible model
→ the model begins to define permissible distinctions
→ what is discovered but contradicts the model is dismissed as irrelevant
The decisive problem is neither the existence of form nor its practical efficiency. It arises when form gains authority over the subject’s original relationship to what was distinguished. A mismatch between reality and the model no longer prompts investigation of the model: the mismatch is declared error, noise, or nonexistent.
The capacity to transform the world according to a model does not grant that model the right to exhaust the world.
Questions for Further Investigation
- Which distinction was retained before the model was created, and which subject established it?
- At what point did the model begin to participate in other subjects’ actions?
- Can a new distinction still lead to revision of the model?
- When does conformity to the model change from an indicator into a condition for recognizing reality?
- Does simulation require the referent’s disappearance, or is it sufficient that the referent ceases to serve as a criterion?
- How can we distinguish the conscious construction of a new reality from the closure of the space of distinction by an accepted model?
- Can simulation be identified without declaring the subject’s experience “unreal”?
Concise Formula
Simulation is not merely the creation of a similar image; it is a transition in which a model participates in producing the signs of reality and acquires authority over the criteria by which reality is recognized.
Sources
- Jean Baudrillard, Simulacres et Simulation (1981), “The Precession of Simulacra.” English excerpt hosted by Stanford University.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Jean Baudrillard.
- Simulacrum and hyperreality — related concepts whose boundaries are examined separately.